Consideration of the Out-of-Phase Operating Conditions of Generators in the Power System in Calculating the Currents at the Short-Circuit Fault Initial Moment
Abstract
At present, short-circuit fault currents in electric power systems are calculated in accordance with national standards, which use a number of assumptions. One of these assumptions is neglecting possible out-of-phase operation of synchronous generators in the mode preceding the short-circuit fault. At present, the constantly growing level of short-circuit currents is a factor aggravating the problem of ensuring consistency between the equipment installed in the electric power systems and these currents. Accordingly, more stringent requirements are posed to the accuracy of short-circuit fault analysis methods.
The aim of this work is to estimate the effect the out-of-phase operating conditions of synchronous generators have on the short-circuit current and to decide whether it is advisable to introduce changes in the short-circuit current calculation procedure stipulated by the relevant standards. To this end, the effect the out-of-phase operating conditions of synchronous generators have on the current at the initial moment of a short-circuit fault is studied taking into account the parameters of the mode preceding the short-circuit fault. To analyze the influence of out-of-phase operating conditions of the generators on the short-circuit fault currents, a mathematical model was developed, and case calculations were carried out using the Mathcad software package. The study was carried out for a synchronous generator operating in parallel with the electric power system; factors reflecting the design features of the synchronous generators, their power in the mode preceding the short-circuit fault, and the electrical remoteness of the synchronous generator from the grid were varied. The parameters of the electrical equipment installed in the electric power system of the Republic of Tajikistan were used as initial data.
The effect the static out-of-phase operating conditions of synchronous generators have on the short-circuit current periodic component value has been evaluated. It is shown that calculations of short-circuit currents carried out according to the methods stipulated by the standards that are currently in force, in which out-of-phase operation of synchronous generators is not taken into account, yield overestimated short-circuit current values, and the calculation error can be as much as 14%. It has been recommended to take into account the static out-of-phase operating conditions of synchronous generators in solving matters concerned with coordination of short-circuit current levels, and to improve the methods for calculating short-circuit currents in power systems. The out-of-phase operation of synchronous generators should be taken into account in substantiating the need of replacing the electrical equipment of power plants and substations in view of growing levels of short-circuit currents.
References
2. ГОСТ Р 52735—2007. Короткие замыкания в электроустановках. Методы расчета в электроустановках переменного тока напряжением свыше 1 кВ.
3. Papadopoulos T.A. e.a. Static and Dynamic Calculation of Short-circuit Currents in Synchronous Generators // Proc. Intern. Conf. Power Syst. Trans. Delft, 2011. Pp. 1—7.
4. Глебов И.А., Харламова Е.Ф. Методика обработки опытных данных внезапного трехфазного короткого замыкания гидрогенератора // Известия РАН. Серия «Энергетика». 1999. № 3. С. 153—157.
5. Савина Н.В. и др. Учет нелинейных нагрузок при расчете коротких замыканий // Вестник Амурского гос. ун-та. Серия «Естественные и экономические науки». 2014. Вып. 65. С. 63—72.
6. Wang L. e. a. Methods of Interfacing Rotating Machine Models in Transient Simulation Programs // IEEE Trans. Power Delivery. 2010. V. 25. Iss. 2. Pp. 891—903.
7. Qiantu R. Present Situation of Short Circuit Current Control in Shanghai Power Grid and Countermeasures // Power Syst. Techn. 2005. V. 29 (2). Pp. 78—83.
8. Мамиконянц Л.Г. Анализ некоторых аспектов переходных и асинхронных режимов синхронных и асинхронных машин / под ред. Ю.Г. Шакаряна. М.: ЭЛКС-КМ, 2006.
9. Крючков И.П., Старшинов В.А., Гусев Ю.П., Пиратов М.В. Переходные процессы в электроэнергетических системах. М.: Изд-во МЭИ, 2008.
10. Неклепаев Б.Н., Крючков И.П. Электрическая часть электростанции. СПб.: БЧВ-Петербург, 2013.
11. Колчанова В.А., Колчанова В.А., Исаев Ю.Н., Лопатин В.В. Математические модели синхронного генератора при различных пространственных удалениях точки возмущения // Современные проблемы науки и образования. 2014. № 2 [Электрон. ресурс] https:// science-education.ru/ru/article/view?id=12293 (дата обращения 11.01.2019).
12. Карапетян И.Г., Файбисович Д.Л., Шапиро И.М. Справочник по проектированию электрических сетей / под ред. Д.Л. Файбисовича. М.: ЭНАС, 2012.
--
Для цитирования: Гусев Ю.П., Каюмов А.Г., Говорин В.В. Учет несинфазности генераторов при расчетах токов в начальной момент короткого замыкания // Вестник МЭИ. 2019. № 4. С. 11—17. DOI: 10.24160/1993-6982-2019-4-11-17.
#
1. IEC 60909-0—2016. Short-circuit Surrents in Three Phases A.S. Systems.
2. GOST R 52735—2007. Korotkie Zamykaniya v Elektroustanovkakh. Metody Rascheta v Elektroustanovkakh Peremennogo Toka Napryazheniem Svyshe 1 kV. (in Russian).
3. Papadopoulos T.A. e.a. Static and Dynamic Calculation of Short-circuit Currents in Synchronous Generators. Proc. Intern. Conf. Power Syst. Trans. Delft, 2011:1—7.
4. Glebov I.A., KHarlamova Е.F. Metodika Obrabotki Opytnykh Dannykh Vnezapnogo Trekhfaznogo Korotkogo Zamykaniya Gidrogeneratora. Izvestiya RAN. Seriya «Energetika». 1999;3:153—157. (in Russian).
5. Savina N.V. i dr. Uchet Nelineynykh Nagruzok pri Raschete Korotkikh Zamykaniy. Vestnik Amurskogo Gos. Un-ta. Seriya «Еstestvennye i Ekonomicheskie Nauki» 2014;65:63—72. (in Russian).
6. Wang L. e. a. Methods of Interfacing Rotating Machine Models in Transient Simulation Programs. IEEE Trans. Power Delivery. 2010;25;2:891—903.
7. Qiantu R. Present Situation of Short Circuit Current Control in Shanghai Power Grid and Countermeasures. Power Syst. Techn. 2005;29 (2):78—83.
8. Mamikonyants L.G. Analiz Nekotorykh Aspektov Perekhodnykh i Asinkhronnykh Rezhimov Sinkhronnykh i Asinkhronnykh Mashin. Pod Red. Yu.G. Shakaryana. M.: ELKS-KM, 2006.
9. Kryuchkov I.P., Starshinov V.A., Gusev Yu.P., Piratov M.V. Perekhodnye Protsessy v Elektroenergeticheskikh Sistemakh. M.: Izd-vo MEI, 2008. (in Russian).
10. Neklepaev B.N., Kryuchkov I.P. Elektricheskaya Chast' Elektrostantsii. SPb.: BCHV-Peterburg, 2013. (in Russian).
11. Kolchanova V.A., Kolchanova V.A., Isaev Yu.N., Lopatin V.V. Matematicheskie Modeli Sinkhronnogo Generatora pri Razlichnykh Prostranstvennykh Udaleniyakh Tochki Vozmushcheniya. Sovremennye Problemy Nauki i Obrazovaniya. 2014;2 [Elektron. Resurs] https://science- education.ru/ru/article/view?id=12293 (Data Obrashcheniya 11.01.2019). (in Russian).
12. Karapetyan I.G., Faybisovich D.L., Shapiro I.M. Spravochnik po Proektirovaniyu Elektricheskikh Setey. Pod Red. D.L. Faybisovicha. M.: ENAS, 2012. (in Russian).
--
For citation: Gusev Yu.P., Kayumov A.G., Govorin V.V Consideration of the Out-of-Phase Operating Conditions of Generators in the Power System in Calculating the Currents at the Short-Circuit Fault Initial Moment. Bulletin of MPEI. 2019;4:11—17. (in Russian). DOI: 10.24160/1993-6982-2019-4-11-17.
