Estimating the Error of Calculating the Load Losses in 6—10 kV Distribution Electric Networks
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24160/1993-6982-2021-5-37-43Keywords:
distribution electric network, electric power losses, method of average loads, RAP-10-st computer program, load loss determination error, transformer loading nonuniformityAbstract
The aim of the study is to estimate the level of load losses for actual (nonuniform) loading of transformer substations in comparison with the load loss level under the conditions of their being uniformly loaded for a typical 6 kV urban distribution electric network.
The extent to which such networks are equipped with automated information and measurement systems for fiscal electricity metering is extremely poor. Therefore, not only the load curves of the 6--10/0.4 kV substation transformers, but also their load factors are unknown in the majority of cases. Under these conditions, in calculating the load losses in 6--10 kV distribution electric networks, it is assumed that all substation transformers are uniformly (equally) loaded. The load losses in these electrical networks are calculated with a certain error associated with the assumption according to which the substation transformers are supposed to be uniformly loaded. Under these conditions, estimation of this error becomes of issue.
The article describes the modeling, calculation and analysis of technical losses of electricity under the conditions of nonuniformly loaded transformers of a typical urban distribution network consisting of four transformers and four cables interconnecting them. The modeling and calculation of power losses were carried out using the RAP-10-st computer program for several different groups of transformer loading factors. Within each group, different subgroups were produced by rearranging the group loading factors. Each subgroup modeled a nonuniform transformers loading mode in the studied network. For each of these modes, the power losses were calculated and studied with the use of the RAP-10-st computer program.
A conclusion has been drawn from the obtained analysis results regarding the error in determining the load losses associated with the assumption about the uniform loading of the substation transformers in the network. The obtained results may prompt electric grid companies to increase the extent of fitting their networks with automated information and measurement systems for fiscal electricity metering to improve the accuracy of determining the load losses.
References
2. Садыкова Ф.М. Анализ потерь электрической энергии и пути их снижения в городских электрических сетях г. Махачкалы. Нормирование технологических потерь электрической энергии // Системные технологии. 2014. № 12. С. 1—6.
3. Пузырева Е.В. Анализ потерь электроэнергии в распределительных сетях // Энергетика: управление, качество и эффективность использования энергоресурсов: Сборник трудов VIII Междунар. науч.-техн. конф. 2015. С. 123—126.
4. Velinov E. e. a. «Leaky Bucket» of Kazakhstan's Power Grid: Losses and Inefficient Distribution of Electric Power // Energies. 2020. V. 13(11). Рр. 1—19.
5. Приказ Минэнерго РФ № 326 от 30.12.2008 г. Об организации в Министерстве энергетики Российской федерации работы по утверждению нормативов технологических потерь электроэнергии при ее передаче по электрическим сетям.
6. Железко Ю.С. Потери электроэнергии. Реактивная мощность. Качество электроэнергии: руководство для практических расчетов. М.: ЭНАС, 2009.
7. Sadovskaia K., Bogdanov D., Honkapuro S., Breyer C. Power Transmission and Distribution Losses – A Model Based on Available Empirical Data and Future Trends for all Countries Globally // Intern. J. Electrical Power and Energy Systems. 2019. V. 107. Рp. 98—109.
8. Pazderin A.A., Pazderin A.V., Morozenko N.A., Chernykh I.V. Electric Losses Flow Distribution Method for Power Systems (Utilities) // Proc. Х Intern. Sci. Symp. Electrical Power Eng. 2019. Рp. 43—47.
9. Manito A.R.A. e. a. Technical and Non-technical Losses Calculation in Distribution Grids Using a Defined Equivalent Operational Impedance // IET Generation. Transmission and Distribution. 2019. V. 13(8). Рp. 1315—1323.
10. Пономаренко О.И., Редин С.Н., Дичина О.В. Расчёт технологических потерь электроэнергии в распределительных сетях 6–10/0,4 кВ на среднесрочных интервалах времени // Энергетик. 2016. № 4. С. 3—8.
11. Кошкин А.А. АИИС КУЭ ОАО «ЕЭСКЭ — история совершенствования системы учета // Электроэнергия. Передача и распределение. 2011. № 6(6). С. 54—58.
12. Гуков П.О. Анализ влияния распределения нагрузки в воздушных линиях 10 кВ на величину потерь мощности. // Вестник Воронежского гос. аграрного ун-та. 2016. № 1(48). С. 93—97.
13. РАП-Стандарт: программный комплекс для расчета, анализа и нормирования потерь электроэнергии в сетях всех напряжений энергоснабжающих организаций [Электрон. ресурс] www.rap-standart.ru (дата обращения 25.03.2021).
14. Бухвал А.В., Швек Р.Р., Юдин М.А. К вопросу о потерях электроэнергии в силовом трансформаторе 10/0,4 кВ // Инновации в сельском хозяйстве. 2015. № 1(11). С. 26—28.
15. Туганбаев А.А. Высшая математика. Функции многих переменных, двойные и тройные интегралы. М.: Флинта, 2019.
---
Для цитирования: Варга А.А., Шведов Г.В. Оценка погрешности расчета нагрузочных потерь электроэнергии в распределительных электрических сетях напряжением 6—10 кВ // Вестник МЭИ. 2021. № 5. С. 37—43. DOI: 10.24160/1993-6982-2021-5-37-43.
#
1. Shvedov G.V., Sipacheva O.V., Savchenko O.V. Poteri Elektroenergii pri ee Transporte po Еlektricheskim Setyam: Raschet, Analiz, Normirovanie i Snizhenie. M.: Izdat. Dom MEI, 2013. (in Russian).
2. Sadykova F.M. Analiz Poter' Elektricheskoy Energii i Puti Ikh Snizheniya v Gorodskikh Elektricheskikh Setyakh g. Makhachkaly. Normirovanie Tekhnologicheskikh Poter' Elektricheskoy Energii. Sistemnye Tekhnologii. 2014;12:1—6. (in Russian).
3. Puzyreva E.V. Analiz Poter' Elektroenergii v Raspredelitel'nykh Setyakh. Energetika: Upravlenie, Kachestvo i Effektivnost' Ispol'zovaniya Energoresursov: Sbornik Trudov VIII Mezhdunar. Nauch.-tekhn. Konf. 2015:123—126. (in Russian).
4. Velinov E. e. a. «Leaky Bucket» of Kazakhstan's Power Grid: Losses and Inefficient Distribution of Electric Power. Energies. 2020;13(11):1—19.
5. Prikaz Minenergo RF № 326 ot 30.12.2008 g. Ob Organizatsii v Ministerstve Energetiki Rossiyskoy Federatsii Raboty po Utverzhdeniyu Normativov Tekhnologicheskikh Poter' Elektroenergii pri ee Peredache po Elektricheskim Setyam. (in Russian).
6. Zhelezko Yu.S. Poteri Elektroenergii. Reaktivnaya Moshchnost'. Kachestvo Elektroenergii: Rukovodstvo dlya Prakticheskikh Raschetov. M.: ENAS, 2009. (in Russian).
7. Sadovskaia K., Bogdanov D., Honkapuro S., Breyer C. Power Transmission and Distribution Losses – A Model Based on Available Empirical Data and Future Trends for all Countries Globally. Intern. J. Electrical Power and Energy Systems. 2019;107:98—109.
8. Pazderin A.A., Pazderin A.V., Morozenko N.A., Chernykh I.V. Electric Losses Flow Distribution Method for Power Systems (Utilities). Proc. X Intern. Sci. Symp. Electrical Power Eng. 2019:43—47.
9. Manito A.R.A. e. a. Technical and Non-technical Losses Calculation in Distribution Grids Using a Defined Equivalent Operational Impedance. IET Generation. Transmission and Distribution. 2019;13(8):1315—1323.
10. Ponomarenko O.I., Redin S.N., Dichina O.V. Raschet Tekhnologicheskikh Poter' Elektroenergii v Raspredelitel'nykh Setyakh 6–10/0,4 kV na Srednesrochnykh Intervalakh Vremeni. Energetik. 2016;4:3—8. (in Russian).
11. Koshkin A.A. AIIS KUE OAO «EESKE — Istoriya Sovershenstvovaniya Sistemy Ucheta. Elektroenergiya. Peredacha i Raspredelenie. 2011;6(6):54—58. (in Russian).
12. Gukov P.O. Analiz Vliyaniya Raspredeleniya Nagruzki v Vozdushnykh Liniyakh 10 kV na Velichinu Poter' Moshchnosti. Vestnik Voronezhskogo Gos. Agrarnogo Un-ta. 2016;1(48):93—97. (in Russian).
13. RAP-Standart: Programmnyy Kompleks dlya Rascheta, Analiza i Normirovaniya Poter' Elektroenergii v Setyakh Vsekh Napryazheniy Energosnabzhayushchikh Organizatsiy [Elektron. Resurs] www.rap-standart.ru (Data Obrashcheniya 25.03.2021). (in Russian).
14. Bukhval A.V., Shvek R.R., Yudin M.A. K Voprosu o Poteryakh Elektroenergii v Silovom Transformatore 10/0,4 Kv. Innovatsii v Sel'skom Khozyaystve. 2015;1(11):26—28. (in Russian).
15. Tuganbaev A.A. Vysshaya Matematika. Funktsii Mnogikh Peremennykh, Dvoynye i Troynye Integraly. M.: Flinta, 2019. (in Russian).
---
For citation: Varga A.A., Shvedov G.V. Estimating the Error of Calculating the Load Losses in 6—10 kV Distribution Electric Networks. Bulletin of MPEI. 2021;5:37—43. (in Russian). DOI: 10.24160/1993-6982-2021-5-37-43.
